Securing Australia's future
At last a budget with minimal changes to superannuation. But is it a missed opportunity?
The 2022/23 Budget only includes one widely applicable change to superannuation - an extension of pension minimum drawdown relief (see below for details). This year of respite will be welcomed by an industry still struggling to digest a long and complex pipeline of changes implemented in recent years while also preparing for previously announced initiatives taking effect over the next couple of years (as outlined below).
The lack of change also supports the Government’s desired positioning ahead of the election as the party that can be trusted not to meddle with the superannuation system – in particular, ruling out any adverse tax changes such as some of the policies that Labor took to the previous election.
While some stability is welcome, there are some changes Mercer would like to have seen – in particular some concrete measures to work at reducing the gender super gap and to improve the fairness of the super tax concessions regime – see our feature article: Gender superannuation savings gap – she’ll be right?
The Budget includes a further 12-month extension of the COVID-19 temporary relief under which the minimum superannuation pension drawdown rates have been halved for the three years to 30 June 2022.
As part of its response to the coronavirus pandemic in early 2020, the Government reduced the superannuation minimum drawdown rates by 50% for the 2019‑20 and 2020‑21 income years. Last year the Government extended the reduction to 2021-22 and it has now undertaken to provide a further 12 months extension, until 30 June 2023.
The minimum drawdown requirements determine the minimum amount of a pension that a retiree has to draw from their superannuation in order to qualify for tax concessions. The Budget papers indicate that the extension recognises the continuing volatility of financial markets and will allow retirees to avoid selling assets in order to satisfy the minimum drawdown requirement.
The argument for an extension of the drawdown relief seems fairly thin given the recovery in share markets since the pandemic induced fall in early 2020.
However, volatility has certainly increased since the Russian invasion of Ukraine and the extension of the drawdown relief gives the Government the opportunity to promote itself as the party that will best protect the interests of self-funded retirees during the election campaign. It also avoids the potential otherwise, for the scheduled expiry of the current relief at 30 June 2022, to be portrayed (albeit unreasonably) as an adverse change.
It will be interesting to see if Labour commits to the same extension if it wins the election, as the Coalition has framed this measure as dependent on it being returned to Government.
Implications for super fund trustees
Implications for employers
Implications for individuals
The Budget also included two narrowly applying superannuation-related measures and a change to reduce disincentives for pensioners continuing some work during retirement:
As noted above, while the 2022-23 Budget left super relatively untouched, a substantial number of previously legislated or announced initiatives are scheduled to take effect over the next couple of years. A selection of these measures is outlined in the tables below.
1 July 2022 changes already legislated
Some important changes to superannuation will occur from 1 July 2022 under current legislation, including a number of measures announced in last year’s Budget and legislated since then.
|
Change from 1 July 2022 (already legislated) |
Superannuation Guarantee (SG) |
|
Work Test for voluntary superannuation contributions |
|
Downsizer contributions |
|
First Home Super Saver Scheme (FHSSS) |
|
APRA Performance Test |
|
|
Changes previously announced but not yet legislated
Superannuation and retirement-related measures previously announced but not yet legislated include:
Financial Accountability Regime (FAR) |
|
Compensation Scheme of Last Resort (CSLR) |
|
New financial reporting and auditing obligations for super funds |
|
Non-arm’s length expense (NALE) provisions |
|
Two year commutation option for legacy pension products
|
|
Improving the Pension Loans Scheme (PLS)
|
A Bill currently before Parliament includes changes announced in the 2021/22 Budget which would, from 1 July 2022:
|
The Women’s Budget Statement released with the 2022-23 Budget recognises the significance of the current gender gap in pay and superannuation savings for women. In particular, it acknowledges the impact of prolonged historical, lower female workforce participation rates and adverse earnings differentials has led to markedly lower current median super balances for women compared with men – the gap peaking at almost 35% between the ages of 50-54 and still at 23.4% for the retirement age bracket of 60-64 (based on 2018-19 data).
Based on the Women’s Budget Statement, the Government’s overall assessment is that “the most effective way to reduce gender gaps in retirement is by reducing them in working life.”
The Government calls out a number of contributing factors to the superannuation savings gap including:
Accepting the problem exists and needs to be better addressed, the Government points to a range of measures it supports (most of which have been previously announced or implemented), to reduce the superannuation gender gap over time by:
A problem cannot be addressed unless it is recognised and understood. The Government has called out the significance of the issue of the superannuation savings gender gap and the range of measures it considers are sufficient to address and reduce the problem – over time.
However, these measures run the risk of proving inadequate over the long term. Also for the generation of women in the mid to later stages of their working life, those measures will not come soon enough to make a significant difference to their position at retirement – through no fault of their own. It is not enough to simply acknowledge their predicament as a by-product of history and move on.
In Mercer’s view, there is much more that could be done now to improve the effectiveness of the super system to build sustainable and equitable retirement savings for men and women and in doing so tackle head on the gender super gap for women at all stages of their working life. We suggest consideration of:
Fixing superannuation concessions by:
Funding the above and rebalancing super savings away from higher income earners (predominately men) towards lower income earners (predominately women) by:
For more on these proposals please refer to the Mercer thought leadership paper:
Mercer, Fixing super tax concessions – A fairer system for all Australians February 2022.
This content is intended to inform clients of Mercer’s views on particular issues. It is not intended to be provided to any person as a retail client and should not be relied upon or used as a substitute for professional advice specific to a client’s individual circumstances. Whilst Mercer believes the prospective information and forward looking statements made by Mercer in this report are based on reasonable grounds, they are predictive in character and may therefore be affected by inaccurate assumptions or by known or unknown risks and uncertainties. This content has been prepared by Mercer Consulting (Australia) Pty Ltd (MCAPL) ABN 55 153 168 140, Australian Financial Services Licence #411770. Any advice contained in this content is of a general nature only and does not take into account the personal needs and circumstances of any particular individual. Prior to acting on any information contained in this content you need to take into account your own financial circumstances, consider the Product Disclosure Statement for any product you are considering and seek advice from a licensed, or appropriately authorised financial adviser if you are unsure of what action to take. ‘MERCER’ is a registered trademark of Mercer (Australia) Pty Ltd ABN 32 005 315 917.
Copyright 2022 Mercer LLC. All rights reserved.
No matter your industry, we’re here to help you find the extra value in your investments so you can stay focused on your business and priorities.
Has your fund considered its next move? Let us help you imagine a brighter future for your members in a rapidly changing environment.
An effective talent strategy means embracing the needs of a diverse workforce while navigating the future of work. Let’s make your people your best asset.
To learn how Mercer can assist your organisation with the outcomes from the Australian Federal Budget please complete your details below